Why True School Choice Requires a Free Market

After pointing out the failures of public schooling here and here, now is probably a good time for the upside of the story. After all, given how broken the current system is, there have got to be better alternatives! And there are.

While modern technology has bettered the lives of hundreds of millions across the globe in many different ways, the education system has hardly been on the forefront in taking advantage of these revolutionary new tools. Which should be no surprise considering the heavy hand government has in schooling..

Yet the cracks are beginning to show, as an increasing number of parents consider homeschooling their children or free_market_educationat least sending them to private schools. Or, as a free market economist might put it; the market is starting to reject the public “education” system that persists in churning out ever dumber students despite rising tuition fees.

In the United States 73 percent of respondents to a public opinion survey said they support school choice. Furthermore, more than 6 out of 10 parents said they would send one or all of their children to a different school “if given the financial opportunity”. They also feel there aren’t enough school options for their children. On the other side of the pond, a UK government report found that “too many pupils drift, become disenchanted with school or get into trouble and drop out at 16”, and that “A large number of adults lack vital skills in literacy and numeracy”. In addition, British state education appears to entrench social segregation rather than improve social mobility.

Although no private school receives taxpayer funding most are still subject to the same regulations as public schools if they are to be formally accredited, meaning tuition fees can be very high. Consequently, homeschooling can be a more viable alternative for many parents. In fact, the number of homeschooled kids in the United States is rising steadily, and has been for several decades. Unfortunately not all parents in the world have that choice, as many governments mandate public education. And even those that do often find themselves under considerable peer pressure as a result of some of the common misconceptions surrounding homeschooling.

One of those misconceptions, and possibly the most persistent one, has to do with the perceived lack of socialization of homeschooled kids. After all, the theory goes, if you don’t go to public school you spend less time around other people, increasing your chances of becoming a social misfit. Still, the statistics don’t bear this out.

A 2003 research survey of adults who were homeschooled found that homeschool graduates are much more involved in their community, as well as more likely to be engaged citizens than the general population. Moreover, homeschool graduates were found to be more content and nearly all were glad to have been homeschooled, while more than 8 out of 10 said they would homeschool their children (74 percent already were). Needless to say, the above cannot be said to be typical of social misfits. In the words of the late Dr. Raymond Moore, author of over 60 books and articles on human development: “The idea that children need to be around many other youngsters in order to be socialized is perhaps the most dangerous and extravagant myth in education and child rearing today.”

The point here, however, is not necessarily to make the case for one type of schooling over another. Regardless of one’s opinion on what is best for a child’s development, the issue is whether the current system truly provides parents with options. Given the laws many governments have put in place to force children into public schools, the answer is obvious. Fortunately there are still some countries where government regulation is a lot less draconian. Nonetheless, the very existence of a public school system as well as economic conditions aggravated by central planning, severely limit school choice even in those countries.

And that is why we need a free market in education.

Advertisements

Share Your Thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s